After much deliberation, Dan Meyer and I are very pleased to announce the winners of this summer's #MTT2K prize for the most entertaining and enlightening video engaging Khan Academy.
Of course, the real winners of the competition are everyone who looked critically at Khan Academy (and looked critically at its critics) and developed a more nuanced view. If after reading some of the conversation generated about Khan Academy this summer, you have a stronger position that Khan Academy is [completely awesome/situationally useful/seriously problematic] then I'm pleased to have played a tiny role in nudging the conversation.
But this post is about the prize winners! And we have four great videos.
Grand Prize
The Grand Prize, by unanimous decision (and almost the winner of the People's Choice as well) is Michael Pershan's What if Khan Academy was Made in Japan? There were two main types of videos: ones that critiqued the pedagogical moves within Khan's lectures (the theme is well articulated by Chris Danielson and Michael Goldenberg in print here) and ones that raised questions about about the overall approach to learning articulated by Khan and colleagues. Michael's video was the best of the latter category.
Michael's piece is carefully researched, charmingly presented, offers an incisive critique of the Khan/Flipped paradigm, and concludes with an example of an alternative model. Dan and I also have blogger-crushes on him, and we think he's making tremendous online contributions to math education through Math Mistakes, his blog, and his Twitter stream. And he's a third year teacher in NYC, so unless he's sold some stock to pay for a comfortable lifestyle, he can probably use a couple of bucks.
People's Choice Award
The People's Choice award, voted on by you the people, goes to Dr. Tae's The History of the Korean War brought to you by UniversiTae and presented by Dr. Tae. It is, by far, the funniest of the entries, and certainly one of the ones most imbued with the satirical spirit of the original MTT2K. It has among the highest production values of the entries, and walks a line between silly and savage that leaves you wondering where he's poking at Khan and where he's just aiming for laughs. Be forewarned, it's a pretty fierce critique.
Second Place
The second place winner was Kate Nowak's commentary on Khan's video about the Coordinate Plane. Kate's video is among those that address Khan's pedagogical moves within each lecture. It's a fair critique, offering specific points of praise, probing questions, and targeted concerns.
As a non-math educator, one of the things that I learned from watching the whole set of videos was the tremendous depth of math-teaching knowledge contained in the math education community. Experienced educators, researchers, and educators drawing from research have a very rich sense of where kids are likely to get stuck, and the kinds of errors that novice math educators, even famous ones, might make. Kate's video does a great job of surfacing this math-teaching wisdom.
Another of my favorite features is that since she uses Mozilla's Popcorn Maker, it's a very easy model to emulate. If math educators or department heads are thinking of using an #MTT2K exercise for a class or in-service, Kate shows a model that people can use without a ton of time or technical skill.
I can't actually embed the video, but here it is.
Third Place
And the third place goes to Susan Jones, primarily for the inclusion of talking robots. Was it too much to ask, people? Talking robots? Could I have made it more clear that we wanted talking robots? Susan thought, "no, Justin, that's not too much to ask" and so she gets 100 bucks. She also has a great evaluation of a Khan video on exponents, a neat alternative presentation, and she used this as a project to teach herself animation. In the spirit of all great learners, she submitted four drafts of the same video as the contest went on.
Conclusion
To all the Khan-test entrants, thanks for your contributions to the public dialogue, and I would encourage everyone to view all of the videos some fall afternoon while you are avoiding grading a stack of papers. Special mentions go out to Gary Rubenstien for having the most entries, Rhett Allain for provoking the most vitriolic reaction, and to John Golden and David Coffey for putting some junk on the Internet that started a summer of very productive conversation.
In the week ahead, I may post more broadly about what I learned from the #MTT2K discussions this summer: maybe something on the role and power of satire and maybe something else on my take on Khan's micro-pedagogy within lectures and his organization's larger approach. Maybe Dan will post on one of those things, and I'll get a break and just link to that.
For now, I'll leave with this thought: the media has a vested interest in lionizing technology and finding silver bullets (to mix metaphors, which may lead to dead were-lions). The future solutions we need will be nuanced and contextual. This is not the last time educators will need to push back on the media in the ed-tech space and ask for some deeper conversations.
For regular updates, follow me on Twitter at @bjfr and for my papers, presentations and so forth, visit EdTechResearcher.
Tags:
|
|
|
===================please note most of this column is due to be re-edited we hope to issue a list of yunus top 10 stories but when it comes to solutions matching those challeges there's all to play for as web3 is humanity's last chnace to leap ahead
hottest youth-spring question of our life and times-can online education end youth unemployment for ever ? yes but only if you help map how!
Breaking News to action now!
About Pro-Youth economics at Norman Macrae Foundation online library of norman macrae - The Economist's Unacknowledged Giant -videos 1 2 -fansweb NMFoundation- youth projects - include yunuschoolusa
fullest press reports Grameen Brand Partnership Architecture
exponential impact advisory: the social business youth networks inspired by muhammad yunus -without which millennium goal actions networks would be way behind are worth far more than any individual parts according to Norman Macrae Foundation trilliondollaraudit methodology and charter notespace
Beyond the extraordinary investment of the members bank at Grameen, and the approximate third share its members foundation holds in grameenphone, here is our Unofficial League Table of Most Impactful Social Business Investments around yunus - last update 1 dec 2012
! Grameen Solar
2 Grameen Mobile Nursing nets and college
3 Portfolio of investments linkedin by Japan
4 Portfolio of youth-led networking inventions in US educationsystem tertiar and secondary - transparency note NM Foundation has minor donation/loan interest
5 Investments in Grameen as collaboration brand linked in out of paris- the origin of global social business partnership funds
6 OpenTech investments of Grameen Intel
-------- while not controlled by yunus we see wholeplanetfoundation microcredit investment table and conscious capitalsm movements and hugely important to advancing pro-youth economicsmission of friends of youth and yunus
email chris.macrae@yahoo.co.ukif you have questions or recommendations of entries that should be in this league table
-please read notes about what pro-youth economists mean by superapps being most
© 2024 Created by chris macrae. Powered by